Skip to main content

Leveling Off & Powerwatch Update

For the first time, I've hit consecutive weeks where my weight hasn't budged, hovering around 158. This isn't a bad thing as I don't have that much extra body fat left to lose.

It's been a brutally cold winter, so I haven't been able to ride my bike into work as much or walk my dogs as long. So, my natural weight is probably a couple of pounds less than what it is now on a 2000 calorie a day budget. I also had a gut buster of a guys weekend the weekend before last, so that skewed my numbers a little. But, it's clear that my weight loss is slowing down. The reduced activity has me constantly bumping up against my calorie consumption rate throughout the day in my Fitbit dashboard and makes me jealous of those who live in warmer climates. I'd imagine they'd probably tell me to try going for a walk in July when it's 90 degrees at night.

Speaking of the Fitbit, my new human powered, thermoelectric replacement - the Matrix Powerwatch, has struck me as only ok. The step counter accuracy is pretty horrible. It just can't seem to differentiate wrist movements from actual steps that well. I remember this was a problem with the first generation of wrist-worn fitness trackers, but my wife's Fitbit Alta is now just as accurate as my hip-worn Fitbit One.


It seems as though my step total is usually about half of what the Powerwatch reports, so maybe I could just use that as a rule of thumb. I'm not sure I'm ready to sacrifice that much accuracy for throwing away another charging cable though. I emailed the company, and they seemed to acknowledge the problem but said they'll be pushing out a software update soon that will improve it. I'd be surprised if that helps the situation all that much, however. I can't imagine this is something that went unnoticed during development or that their testers kept their watch hand in their pocket all day.

Also, the sleep timer is nothing more than a glorified stopwatch for your sleep. It doesn't give you any feedback for how well you slept but just how long you started the timer until the time you got up and started moving around. If you forget to hit the stop button when you wake up, it does figure out once you start moving again to turn the timer off. So, I guess it scores a point there. I never use the sleep timer on my Fitbit, so this was sort of an add-on feature for me. I generally know when I have a lousy night's sleep, and if I do, I didn't do it deliberately (and frankly, I'd rather not see the reminder that I only got 4 hours of sleep).

Lastly, the stopwatch is somewhat useless. You cannot see how much time has elapsed unless you hit pause or stop. I think it's because your body heat barely generates enough power for it to do its critical duties that displaying a running timer requires too much juice. It just displays "Running" until you stop or pause it. This is kind of annoying, but I could live with it if the step tracker worked properly.


This thing claims to have the most accurate calorie burning measurement of any fitness tracker precisely because it measures your body heat, but this claim appears to be a bunch of baloney. I worked pretty hard today doing stuff around my weekend home - 16,000 steps (31,000 steps according to the Powerwatch), but it says I only burned 2000 calories while my Fitbit says 2900. My back of the napkin BMR (body weight x 11) is 1738 calories burned if I did nothing but lay around all day.

So, we'll see. I tried to read some reviews on it to see if others noticed this step problem, but I honestly think I'm probably 1 of about 50 people who actually received the watch as all of the reviews seem to be by tech bloggers who just got a quick hands-on at a trade show.

I might give it a little more time and see if the upcoming software update improves it, but I may just throw it on Ebay now since you can't get them immediately anywhere else. There are literally only a few on Ebay now, and it looks like I can probably get a little over my purchase price.

It's really too bad. Appearance wise, it was starting to grow on me, and I really high hopes for this really unique watch. Hopefully, they'll get all the kinks worked out in the second generation or maybe another company will give thermoelectric watches a try. My first requirement for a watch is dependability but a close second is usefulness. My solar-powered Casio Protrek can't track steps, but it can do lots of other things that this can't and where they overlap, such as with the stopwatch and telling time (the Protrek has a world clock), the Casio simply works better.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Second Look at Exercise

I'll be a first time dad in the next week or two, and I'm already dealing with the time crunch and cheapo routine disruptive life events. Being a cheapo means improvising, so sometimes you need to rethink methodologies to adapt to changing circumstances. My 9 month pregnant wife has been joining me on my dog walks in order to get some exercise herself, and she can't go as far as I can for as far along as she is. Also, she has a hankering for dining out more often than we normally do, so it adds a little more guesswork to my calorie estimates when my margins are already running pretty thin. Add in doctors appointments, chores and other prep tasks, and a lot of my extra time for walking is just vanishing. It's only going to get harder once this baby gets here. It's my fault for allowing my weight to run away from me such that I'm in a position now to where I'm trying to lose a lot of weight quickly before the baby arrives. I'm losing weight steadily...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Mechanics

Ok, now that you've read through the high level stuff, let's get down to brass tacks: The reality is, you're going to want to make some changes to your daily routine, but how much you do depends on how much you want to lose and how quickly you want to lose it. There's nothing wrong with going at a slower pace, but I would just advise that you adjust your diet enough that you're seeing enough consistent enough gains that you stick with it. Remember, as long as you're still logging food, odds are you're still losing weight. I've already mentioned that you'll need a pedometer or fitness tracker. That needs to become a permanent extension of your body. You don't need to be a gym rat (in fact, you should have already cancelled your gym membership by now), but it's hard to be completely sedentary and still run calorie deficits. Or, put another way, a little bit of activity will give you a lot more wiggle room in your diet every day. A 10,000...
Post a Comment
Read more

Chopping Down Costs & Fat

I've spent a lot of time talking about how gym memberships are a complete waste of time and money. For most people, they make about as much sense as skipping all your errands to spend the day taking joyrides up and down a toll road. The fact is, we all have chores that need to get done around the house which all represent opportunities for exercise and cost savings by not paying someone else to do them for you. They may not be as physically demanding as splitting wood, but they all involve doing things that need to get done anyway and, more importantly, occupying your time by doing something other than eating, the leading cause of fatness. Now, I'm not proposing that you start tilling your garden with a fork just to keep yourself out of the kitchen. There's always a delicate balance between efficiency, exercise, cost savings and enjoyment of the task at hand when deciding where to spend extra money for efficiency's sake. For example, I know that I could get my...
Post a Comment
Read more