Skip to main content

Fenix 5X Review: Too Much of a Good Thing?

This car has too much horsepower.

This TV is just too big.

This computer is too damned fast.

This watch is way too advanced.


These are things I've never imagined myself saying, but I think I may have finally met my match with the Fenix 5X. The fitness tracking capabilities are top notch. Battery life worries are practically gone. The sapphire crystal is basically unscratchable. It looks exceptionally sharp and clean. And yet...

I'm not in love with it - at least so far. I've worn some large watches, but this watch requires that you reset your expectations of what a large watch looks and feels like. To give you some perspective, here is a side-by-side of the Fenix, my Casio ProTrek and my Citizen Eco-Drive field watch that I've been wearing recently:
It's hard to appreciate the massive size of this thing, even by this picture. Not only is it the widest watch I've ever tried on, it's also the tallest. I don't wear dress shirts that often, but it takes some tugging and pulling to fit your sleeve over it. It almost reminds me of my wrist-mounted dive computer, which is like wearing a hockey puck on your wrist.

However, the analytics are on this thing are the best. It kicks Fitbit's butt up and down in terms of fitness tracking. In Fitbit's defense, however, I am using a tracker from 2013, so I'm not getting a full dashboard view of their current potential. Still, Garmin's dashboard is exceptionally robust and feature-packed, and it actually integrates pretty well with MyFitnessPal as a nutrition tracker. You can dive into your activities and see every single metric you could possibly want from every workout:

However, when it comes to measuring steps and calorie burning activity, it's almost exactly the same as the Fitbit:

The Garmin does a better job zeroing out our steps during activities like cycling. I clipped my Fitbit on my shirt today as opposed to my pants pocket to try and prevent it from improperly registering cycling revolutions as steps, and it is super close. I suspect the 300 or so more steps on the Fitbit are from when I'm standing up climbing hills rather rather than seated while riding on the flats and downhill. I bet if I clipped it onto my bike frame while I was riding, the Garmin and Fitbit would be almost exactly the same.

It's cool having a heart rate sensor, but ultimately, it's not all that useful - at least for my purposes. It's nice information to see, but it isn't really necessary for reaching your cheapo fitness goals. It's cool that it has pre-loaded maps, but my phone has that capability too. Same goes for the sleep tracking, which this does automatically. I slept horribly the night before and great last night, but I didn't need this to tell me that.

The only thing I can really see where this thing shines is for GPS tracking while running. Again, this is something that my phone can do, but I can see how it would be really nice to see your speed, time and distance all in one dashboard on your wrist. I'm not sure that it's worth keeping a $540 watch for those specialized use cases. In fact, I have an old Garmin Forerunner running watch in a drawer that I can wear just for those occasions, and it's super small and light like a Timex Ironman.

I'll probably give this baby a few more days before I likely turn around and sell it. I consider myself a fitness geek, but eventually geekiness runs into the limits of practicality. This definitely toes the line if it doesn't hurdle it altogether. More and more I'm thinking I'm just a "dumbwatch" kind of guy.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Weekly Updates (2/9/2018)

Week one of BUD/S training is going OK. I can do everything but all the sit-ups (and of course the swimming, due to the lack of pool). The best I could bang out with sit-ups were 2 sets of 20, 1 of 15 and 1 of 10. But, at least I haven't experienced any soreness yet. Just the little bit of additional activity has me losing even slightly more weight. I'm holding my weight under the 40 pound loss benchmark on the scale every day now, and I'm feeling really good. I've almost forgotten how much I enjoyed running, which I'm sure has a lot to do with how much less of a strain it is on my body. I'm not going to lie - it was nothing short of exhilarating holding down the weight button on the treadmill for as long as it took to reduce the weight setting from 198 to 157- my weight from the last time I set it. It was definitely a bizarre experience. After the PowerWatch bust, I decided to try out another activity tracker watch. So, I ordered a Garmin Fenix 5X. It's...
Post a Comment
Read more

Chopping Down Costs & Fat

I've spent a lot of time talking about how gym memberships are a complete waste of time and money. For most people, they make about as much sense as skipping all your errands to spend the day taking joyrides up and down a toll road. The fact is, we all have chores that need to get done around the house which all represent opportunities for exercise and cost savings by not paying someone else to do them for you. They may not be as physically demanding as splitting wood, but they all involve doing things that need to get done anyway and, more importantly, occupying your time by doing something other than eating, the leading cause of fatness. Now, I'm not proposing that you start tilling your garden with a fork just to keep yourself out of the kitchen. There's always a delicate balance between efficiency, exercise, cost savings and enjoyment of the task at hand when deciding where to spend extra money for efficiency's sake. For example, I know that I could get my...
Post a Comment
Read more

Carrying All That Extra Weight Around Is Stupid and Inefficient

If you have a hard time thinking of good reasons for losing weight, how about you try carrying a Thanksgiving turkey around in a backpack everywhere, every day and see how you feel. I'll spare you the trouble: you'll feel horrible. Granted, carrying all the weight you need to lose (give or take) in the form of a Butterball suspended from your back is much more uncomfortable than having it spread over your body throughout your face and all the way down to your toes, but it'll give you some idea of all the extra work your body has to do every day in getting you from point A to B. I remember dismissing all the chatter about how being overweight makes you excessively fatigued as fitness freak happy talk, but it's true. I used to be tired all the time and just chalked it up to the way a normal person feels after a full day's work. And, when I initially started this plan, I felt even worse because I was not only fat and tired but now hungry and grouchy too. But, as the ...
Post a Comment
Read more